Shortlist & Compare Schools
Turns a long list into a scored shortlist of reach, match and safe schools, against what actually matters to you.
What Dev brought · a list off a ranking site
“Twelve universities off a ranking list. I don’t know which are realistic.”
What the prompt returned
Twelve scored against his weighted criteria: nine kept, three dropped. Three reach, four match, two near-certain, with his 1380 SAT against each school’s published middle 50%.
The analysis · Twelve schools chosen by rank, none checked against his record
A shortlist is built on fit rather than rankings: what is taught and how, the cost after aid, the entry standard against the applicant’s record, and what the applicant actually wants. A balanced list holds reaches, matches and near-certainties, because nine reaches is nine rejections.
- Weighted before scored: the family ranked what mattered before any school was scored, so the table could not be argued backwards from a favourite.
- Two had no major: two of the twelve did not offer mechanical engineering at all, which a ranking table does not tell you.
- Everything marked to confirm: every requirement, fee and score range is tagged [CONFIRM] against the school’s own admissions page, because these change yearly.
Takeaway: weight what matters first, then score every school against it, and keep the list balanced.

